30 ml to 50 ml, One Tap: A Bigger-Size Upsell
Offering the next size up with the real price difference, one tap in the cart, and checking whether a bigger bottle earns more over a full reorder cycle.
Illustrative scenario: a skincare brand whose customers default to the 30 ml serum uses an Upsell in Bigger variant mode to offer the next size up with the real price difference, once the small size is in the cart. No incentive is used, and the article shows why a bigger bottle earns more per order but can earn less per millilitre from customers who reorder reliably.
At a glance
- Challenge
- Most serum orders were the default 30 ml, and the selector never said the 50 ml was only $16 more and cheaper per millilitre.
- Approach
- One Upsell in Bigger variant mode on the hero serum, no incentive, banner and cart swap card, judged on gross profit per customer over a reorder cycle.
- Discount Prime campaign types used
- Upsell
Scenario-based case study: the merchant is fictional and modeled on patterns across Discount Prime stores. Prices, costs and outcome figures are illustrative assumptions for teaching, not measured results from a real store.
Short Answer
When customers default to the smallest size, an Upsell (Upgrade offer) in Bigger variant mode can offer the next size up with the real price difference, and swap one unit in the cart in one tap. It needs an option whose prices strictly increase, like Size, and it keeps the customer's other choices.
Two things to know before you launch:
- The offer appears after the small size is in the cart. Both the product page banner and the cart card work on a cart line; neither changes the size selector before the customer adds to cart.
- A bigger bottle is not automatically more profit. It earns more per order, but if your customers reorder reliably, selling the same volume in bigger bottles can earn less gross profit per millilitre. The math below shows how to check.
Verdant Botanicals is a fictional store used to illustrate the decision. All prices, costs and shares are illustrative assumptions, not results.
Fits / Does Not Fit
| Fits when | Does not fit when |
|---|---|
| One option (size, pack count) has strictly increasing prices | The only options are color or scent at the same price |
| Many small-size buyers never reorder, or each order carries a real fulfillment cost | Most customers reorder the small size on a steady cycle and you earn more per millilitre on it |
| The larger size is the better value per unit, so no incentive is needed | You would need a discount to make the larger size attractive |
| The upgrade is the same product, one step up | The upgrade is a different product (use Better product mode) |
The Scenario and the Data You Need
Verdant Botanicals, a fictional Shopify skincare brand, sells its Hero Serum in 30 ml at $38, 50 ml at $54 and 100 ml at $92. Assume 70% of serum orders are the 30 ml, which the product page selects by default.
Illustrative assumptions:
| Size | Price | Unit cost | Gross profit per bottle | Price per ml | Gross profit per ml |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30 ml | $38 | $8 | $30 | $1.27 | $1.00 |
| 50 ml | $54 | $11 | $43 | $1.08 | $0.86 |
| 100 ml | $92 | $19 | $73 | $0.92 | $0.73 |
Gross profit is price minus unit cost; fees, shipping and fulfillment are excluded unless stated. Data you need: unit costs per size, how many 30 ml buyers reorder and how often, and your cost per order (pick, pack, shipping you pay).
The Options Compared
| Option | What changes | Cost | When it fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Make 50 ml the default variant (theme setting, native) | The selector starts on 50 ml | $0 | You want a nudge before add to cart; easy to test first |
| Show price per ml on the page (theme or unit price, native) | The value case is visible before adding | $0 | Your theme supports unit pricing; works with any approach |
| Upsell, Bigger variant, no incentive | Banner and cart card offer the next size after the small one is added | $0 per upgrade | You want an explicit "only $16 more" moment in the cart |
| Upsell, Better product mode | Swaps to a fixed variant of a different product | n/a | Built for different products, not sizes of one product |
A default variant and an upsell are not mutually exclusive. Setting the default changes what customers see first; the upsell catches customers who still pick the small size.
Does a Bigger Size Earn More? The Math
Per order, the 50 ml earns $13 more gross profit than the 30 ml ($43 vs $30). Over time, it depends on whether the customer would have come back.
Illustrative case: a loyal customer uses 150 ml over a period.
| How they buy 150 ml | Revenue | Gross profit | Orders | Gross profit after $6 per-order cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 × 30 ml | $190 | $150 | 5 | $120 |
| 3 × 50 ml | $162 | $129 | 3 | $111 |
For this loyal customer, the bigger bottle earns less, even after saving two orders' worth of fulfillment. For a customer who would have bought one 30 ml and never returned, the upgrade is +$13. The campaign makes money when enough small-size buyers are one-time buyers, or when your per-order cost is high. Replace the costs, the $6 per-order cost and the reorder pattern with your own numbers before deciding.
This is also why Verdant uses no incentive: the 50 ml is already cheaper per millilitre for the customer, and any discount would come straight out of a smaller gross profit per millilitre.
How Bigger Variant Mode Works
- It finds the ladder for you. For each trigger product, the builder checks which option has strictly increasing prices when the other options are held constant. Size qualifies here ($38, $54, $92). A scent option at one price would show as "not a ladder".
- It offers one step up. 30 ml is offered 50 ml; 50 ml is offered 100 ml; 100 ml gets no offer.
- It keeps other choices. If the serum also had a Scent option, a 30 ml Rose would be offered the 50 ml Rose.
- It prices from the live storefront. The difference shown uses current prices, so
{diff}follows a price change. - The ladder is fixed at activation. If you later reprice so that 100 ml costs less than 50 ml, the ladder is not rebuilt until the campaign is processed again. Until then the card would offer a step that is no longer bigger in price, with a "no extra cost" message. After repricing, reactivate the campaign and check the card.
Settings Used in This Scenario
| Setting | Value |
|---|---|
| Campaign type | Upsell (Upgrade offer); Prime plan or higher |
| Upgrade mode | Bigger variant |
| Products the customer is buying | Specific products: Hero Serum (ladder option: Size) |
| Incentive | No incentive (default) |
| Phrasing template | Upgrade to {title} - only {diff} more |
| Placement | Both (product page banner and cart swap card) |
| Eligibility | All customers |
What the Customer Sees
- A shopper opens the Hero Serum page with 30 ml selected. No banner yet.
- They add the 30 ml. If they stay on the product page, a banner under the buy buttons reads
Upgrade to 50 ml Hero Serum - only $16.00 morewith a Switch button. - In the cart (drawer or page), a swap card shows the same offer with an Upgrade button.
- Either button removes one 30 ml unit and adds one 50 ml unit in a single cart update. A toast reads
Upgraded to 50 ml Hero Serumwith Undo (10 seconds by default).
| Cart | Offer shown | After one tap |
|---|---|---|
| 1 × 30 ml | 50 ml, $16 more | 1 × 50 ml ($54) |
| 2 × 30 ml on one line | 50 ml, $16 more | 1 × 30 ml + 1 × 50 ml; the card offers the remaining 30 ml again |
| 1 × 50 ml (added directly) | 100 ml, $38 more | 1 × 100 ml ($92) |
| 1 × 100 ml | None, top of the ladder | n/a |
With no incentive, nothing is discounted at checkout: each size is charged its normal price however it reached the cart.
Limits and Pre-Launch Tests
- No pre-cart nudge. The banner needs the serum in the cart. If your theme opens a cart drawer after adding, most shoppers will see the cart card, not the banner.
- Specific products only as triggers.
- Stock. A next step that is out of stock is not offered.
| Test input | Expected result |
|---|---|
| Product page, empty cart | No banner |
| Add 30 ml, stay on the page | Banner with 50 ml and $16 |
| Tap Switch, then Undo | 50 ml replaced by 30 ml again |
| Cart with 2 × 30 ml, tap Upgrade once | 1 × 30 ml and 1 × 50 ml |
| 50 ml out of stock | No offer for the 30 ml |
| Reprice a size, reload the cart | Card shows the new difference; reactivate if the order of prices changed |
Measurement and When to Change Course
- Primary metric: gross profit per serum customer over a full reorder cycle, not only per order. Per-order AOV will rise almost by definition.
- Guardrails: size mix (30, 50, 100 ml), Undo rate, and reorder rate and interval for customers who bought the 50 ml through the swap versus 30 ml buyers.
- What Discount Prime records: swapped lines per campaign and their revenue before discount, from paid orders. These are attributed, not incremental; refunds are not subtracted.
- Confounders: new-customer share, promotions, and season (a gifting period changes size mix by itself).
Compare against a baseline period, or alternate periods with the campaign on and off. Without a controlled comparison, treat changes in size mix as directional.
- Continue if gross profit per customer over the reorder cycle holds or rises.
- Adjust to the cart card only if the banner rarely shows on your theme.
- Stop if 50 ml buyers reorder much later and gross profit per customer falls.
For a different premium product rather than a bigger size, see The Derby and the Loafer.
Frequently asked questions
How do I upsell a bigger size of the same product on Shopify?
Use an Upsell (Upgrade offer) in Discount Prime with Upgrade mode set to Bigger variant and pick the product. The builder finds an option whose prices strictly increase, such as Size, and offers the next step up with the price difference. After the customer adds the small size, a banner on the product page and a card in the cart swap one unit to the bigger size in one tap, keeping other options such as scent.
Does the bigger-size upsell change the size selector before the customer adds to cart?
No. The product page banner appears only once the product is already in the cart, and its Switch button swaps the cart line; it does not change the selected variant on the page. If you want a nudge before add to cart, change the default variant or show unit prices in your theme, and keep the upsell for customers who still add the small size.
Why does the Bigger variant upsell say there is nothing bigger to offer?
Because no option has strictly increasing prices when the other options are held constant. Size from $38 to $54 to $92 qualifies; a scent or color option at one price does not. The ladder is checked when the campaign is processed, so if you later reprice sizes out of order, reactivate the campaign and check the cart card, which otherwise may offer a step that is no longer more expensive.
Is selling a bigger size always more profitable?
Per order, usually yes. Per customer, not always: if customers reorder the small size reliably and it earns more gross profit per millilitre, selling the same volume in bigger bottles can earn less, even after saving fulfillment costs on fewer orders. Bigger sizes pay off most when many small-size buyers never reorder or when your cost per order is high. Measure gross profit per customer over a reorder cycle.
Should I add a discount to a bigger-size upsell?
Usually not when the bigger size is already the better value per unit for the customer. A discount comes straight out of a gross profit per unit that is often already lower on the larger size. Show the real price difference first; add an incentive only if testing shows the difference alone does not move customers and the economics still work.
Go deeper
Run this architecture in your store
Every campaign type in this case study is included in Discount Prime, with profit analytics to verify the margin impact.